QUOTE(Mera @ Mar 9 2010, 11:16 PM)

SPOILER (Click to show and click again to hide)
I got the same ending as you from the sound of it, but I didn't kill Mr. Crazy w/ Jayden, and I didn't kill the drug dealer for the 3rd trial w/ Ethan. As such, I picked the wrong ending location with Ethan and ended up with Paige and Jayden both finding Shawn's location (in hind sight I should have had Paige call Ethan about the location, but yeah. XD ). Based on the ending(s) for the characters that I got I can see some of the choices I'll need to differ in, I'm just wondering if something can be done for sure differently to keep Shelby alive and if perhaps he's always the killer. Also something that threw me off: the accident w/ his brother happened 30 years ago. The kids shown appeared to be no older than 10-14 years old. But the game itself states that Shelby is 58 (or was it 48?) not the proper age the killer should have been regardless. Either a really poor oversight, or perhaps it can be done differently/better? I don't know. lol. I think they overlooked a number of things to fit such a big 'twist' in last minute or something. Threw me for a whirl when it happened though, I'll say that. O_o
SPOILER (Click to show and click again to hide)
Oh most definitely, when they started to flash back to earlier events in the game, and all of a sudden they show Shelby doing something I didn't remember doing with him (I can't remember the exact scene, sadly) my jaw hit the floor. I also kinda wonder if, when Shelby reveals why he picked Ethan, if you can see Shelby in the crowd after Jason gets hit by the car.
Also, what made you not kill the drug dealer? I felt the decision to kill him was slightly more justified, considering he was a drug dealer. Had he been some random person who hadn't done anything wrong, then maybe I could see letting him live. That was, if I remember right, the one decision I had to actually pause the game and think about.